gordon.coale
 
Home
 


Weblog Archives

   
 
  Monday  April 5  2004    09: 44 AM

have gun, will travel

The four "civilians" that were killed at Fallujah were hardly civilians. They were mercenaries hired by the Department of Defense. This is more than worrisome. Here are several posts looking at this. The potential for really bad things to come of this are way too great.

Contractors in Iraq: the convergence
by Helena Cobban


This use by the U.S. military of private U.S. contractors for security duty in Iraq is something fairly new and very unsettling in international affairs and international law.

I mean, how weird is it that Paul Bremer, who's the top representative of the U.S. military's top civil-affairs unit, gets protected by contract soldiers, not by the U.S. military itself?

What is the status of all these guys under the Geneva Conventions? They are not acting directly in the military chain of command.

Does that make them "unlawful combatants", I wonder? Or, if taken prisoner, would they be considered to be regular POWs?

Anyway, I learned from ABC News tonight that there are around 15,000 of them there in Iraq now. Many more fighters than even the Brits have in Iraq!

[more]


This is a very good look at this travesty.

Iraq: The Secret Policeman's Other Ball


I started this post -- concerning the role of private military companies and mercenaries in Iraq yesterday. But I was so shocked at what I was finding that I had to sleep on it before I could continue.

[more]


Shine a light from Body and Soul


And Kos has first hand experience with mercenaries...

Mercenaries, war, and my childhood


Unlike the vast majority of people in this country, I actually grew up in a war zone. I witnessed communist guerillas execute students accused of being government collaborators. I was 8 years old, and I remember stepping over a dead body, warm blood flowing from a fresh wound. Dodging bullets while at market. I lived in the midsts of hate the likes of which most of you will never understand (Clinton and Bush hatred is nothing compared to that generated when people kill each other for politics or race or nationality). There's no way I could ever describe the ways this experience colors my worldview.

Back to Iraq, our men and women in uniform are there under orders, trying to make the best of an impossible situation. The war is not their fault, and I will always defend their honor and bravery to the end of my days. But the mercenary is a whole different deal. They willingly enter a war zone, and do so because of the paycheck. They're not there for humanitarian reasons (I doubt they'd donate half their paycheck to the Red Cross or whatever). They're there because the money is DAMN good. They answer to no one except their CEO. They are dangerous, hence international efforts (however fruitless they may be) to ban their use.

So not only was I wrong to say I felt nothing over their deaths, I was lying. I felt way too much. Nobody deserves to die. But in the greater scheme of things, there are a lot of greater tragedies going on in Iraq (51 last month, plus countless civilians and Iraqi police). That those tragedies are essentially ignored these days is, ultimately, the greatest tragedy of all.

[more]


And here come the bad things...

Bodyguards in Iraq turn to 'massive firepower' after attack


American bodyguards in Iraq want to strengthen their weaponry with hand grenades and high-powered machineguns after four private security consultants were murdered in Fallujah last week.

Only coalition soldiers are allowed to carry explosives under existing regulations, leaving up to 20,000 civilian contractors working as guards outgunned by insurgents with rocket-propelled grenades and belt-fed machineguns.

The Coalition Provisional Authority is horrified by the contractors' plans to flout the rules, believing that such action could lead to a serious escalation in violence as the June deadline approaches for power to be transferred to the Iraqis.

On Saturday, however, Malcolm Nance, a former adviser to the CIA and the U.S. National Security Agency who has spent 10 months in Iraq supervising security for businesses and charities, warned that firms would "go heavy" to prevent a repeat of last week's murders.

[more]