gordon.coale
 
Home
 


Weblog Archives

   
 
  Saturday  September 11  2004    07: 27 AM

9/11

My comment three years ago...


I'd have to say that it's worse than it appears.

Too many have died since that day. Too many still to die.

Meteor Blades, at daily KOS, says it well...

A Fitting Commemoration for September 11


I know that September 11th is supposed to be a sacred American day, “our” day to mourn the innocent victims – the 3000 dead and thousands of maimed and permanently traumatized – the day on which everything supposedly changed.

At the risk of being once again called unpatriotic, however, let me suggest that we turn this date into something more than an all-American day of remembrance. For one thing, Americans weren’t the only people who died in the World Trade Center, the Pentagon and in Pennsylvania three years ago. Moreover, another September 11 lives in infamy because of the terrorists who toppled the Chilean government three decades ago and proceeded to kill an estimated 3000 of their countrymen.

I’d like to see September 11th transformed into a day of mourning for victims of terrorists everywhere, whether they live in Northern Ireland or Darfur, Cambodia or Israel, Indonesia or Guatemala, Oklahoma City or Madrid, Beslan or Kuta.

Some people, I suspect, may think I seek to downplay the loss that we - both as a nation and as individuals close to the victims - suffered on that dark day. To dilute the memories of our grief and rage and despair. No way. I’ll never forget where I was when I heard the news. I’ll never erase the memory of watching people leap from the flames to certain death on the streets of Lower Manhattan. I’ll never forget the two days I waited a coast away, wondering if a woman I knew had escaped the killers aboard Flight 175. (She did.)

Appalling and spectacular and searing as those events three years ago were, however, we do a disservice to ourselves to pretend that America suffered uniquely from the machinations of terrorists. What better commemoration than henceforth to remember ALL of terrorism’s victims, planetwide, on September 11?

And what better way to set an example - a standard for those in the world our leaders so often lecture about civilized behavior - than to pledge, as I suggested earlier today, never again to overtly or covertly authorize, order, support, promote, fund, train or wink at terrorists whatever their cause, excuse, justification, rationalization, religion, ideology or helpfulness to real or alleged U.S. interests?

For the United States to renounce terrorism as well as denounce it would take the world that much closer to the day when terrorists are the least of everyone's concerns.

[more]

Juan Cole has an excellent overview on the aftermath.

September 11 and Its Aftermath


Al-Qaeda has succeeded in several of its main goals. It had been trying to convince Muslims that the United States wanted to invade Muslim lands, humiliate Muslim men, and rape Muslim women. Most Muslims found this charge hard to accept. The Bush administration's Iraq invasion, along with the Abu Ghuraib prison torture scandal, was perceived by many Muslims to validate Bin Laden's wisdom and foresightedness.

After the Iraq War, Bin Laden is more popular than George W. Bush even in a significantly secular Muslim country such as Turkey. This is a bizarre finding, a weird turn of events. Turks didn't start out with such an attitude. It grew up in reaction against US policies.

It remains to be seen whether the US will be forced out of Iraq the way it was forced out of Iran in 1979. If so, as al-Zawahiri says, that will be a huge victory. A recent opinion poll did find that over 80 percent of Iraqis want an Islamic state. If Iraq goes Islamist, that will be the biggest victory the movement has had since the rise of the Taliban in Afghanistan. An Islamist Iraq might well be able ultimately to form a joint state with Syria, starting the process of the formation of the Islamic superstate of which Bin Laden dreams.

If the Muslim world can find a way to combine the sophisticated intellectuals and engineers of Damascus and Cairo with the oil wealth of the Persian Gulf, it could well emerge as a 21st century superpower.
[...]

The US is not winning the war on terror. Al-Qaeda also has by no means won. But across a whole range of objectives, al-Qaeda has accomplished more of its than the US has of its.

[more]